On August 5, the Nikkei Stock Average saw its biggest drop ever, a plunge partly blamed on the “Yen Carry Trade” in the foreign exchange market. This trade involves borrowing yen at low interest rates and investing in higher-yielding currencies like the U.S. dollar. When large amounts of these trades are reversed, it can cause the yen to strengthen rapidly, which then impacts the stock market negatively. This isn’t the first time; similar scenarios occurred in 1998 and 2007, leading to market instability.
What is the Yen Carry Trade?
The yen carry trade is a strategy where investors borrow yen at low interest rates and invest in currencies with higher interest rates to profit from the difference. As investors sell yen to buy other currencies, it weakens the yen. However, when they reverse these trades, the yen strengthens.
For nearly eight years, Japan kept its interest rates negative as part of an economic policy, while the U.S. sharply increased its rates. The large difference in interest rates between Japan and the U.S. made the yen carry trade very attractive to investors.
The Historical Context
This isn’t the first time the yen carry trade has surged. The first peak was in 1998 when Japan faced financial instability, making it cheap for foreign investors to borrow yen. The second peak was around 2007, just before the financial crisis, when the U.S. raised rates while Japan’s stayed low. Both times, the unwinding of these trades led to a stronger yen and market instability.
The current boom in yen carry trades was triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. These events caused disruptions in global supply chains, leading to higher prices for food and energy. The U.S. responded by raising interest rates, while Japan kept its rates low, further increasing the attractiveness of the yen carry trade.
The August 5 Stock Market Crash and Yen Carry Trade
On August 5, the Nikkei fell by over 4,000 yen, its biggest drop ever. Some believe the unwinding of yen carry trades contributed to this crash. The Bank of Japan’s decision to raise interest rates unexpectedly narrowed the interest rate gap between Japan and the U.S., reducing the profitability of the carry trade. This led to a rapid unwinding of positions, where investors rushed to buy back yen, causing it to appreciate quickly. As the yen strengthened, investors who had been buying Japanese stocks saw their strategies unravel, leading to a massive sell-off in the stock market.
Has the Unwinding Ended?
Opinions differ among experts. Some believe only 30-40% of these trades have been unwound, while others estimate as much as 75%. Data from the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission suggests that the unwinding may be mostly over, but some positions may still be left.
As of August 9, the yen had stabilized somewhat, and the Nikkei had recovered slightly. However, it may take time for the markets to fully stabilize after such significant movements.
In summary, the yen carry trade is a strategy that can lead to significant market impacts when it unwinds. As we’ve seen in the past, the reversal of these trades can cause market turmoil, affecting currencies and stocks globally. With the recent events, it’s clear that while the yen carry trade can be profitable, it also carries risks that can lead to widespread financial instability.
Atsushi's Life in Korea 